All gizmos

The Trouble With Hoyt-Schermerhorn

More violent complaints are recorded here than anywhere else in Brooklyn. The count has more than tripled since 2006, while the city's barely moved. A third of them are logged at one courthouse. I wanted to know what the rest are.

2026-11

New York City is one of the safest big cities in the world, and by most measures it is about as safe as it has ever been. In 1990 New York had 2,262 murders, more than six a day, and 100,280 robberies, one for every 73 residents and the highest robbery rate of any large American city. Thirty-five years later, in 2025, the city had fewer than one murder a day and a robbery rate in the middle of the pack of large American cities.

Precinct19902025Change
882194294-86.6%
812395364-84.8%
301707264-84.5%
61719275-84%
17927153-83.5%
192225373-83.2%
145351903-83.1%
773789647-82.9%
76976170-82.6%
781371239-82.6%
Change in murder, robbery and felony assault by precinct, 1990 to 2025, from NYPD CompStat historical tables (77 precincts). City murders 2262 in 1990, 305 in 2025.

This progress was universal, if not evenly distributed. The map above shows every police precinct in the city and how its violent crime, counted as murder, robbery and felony assault, has changed since 1990. Of the 75 precincts with a 1990 line, 64 are down 60 percent or more. Three in the northeast Bronx are down only 19 to 26 percent, and the 123rd on Staten Island's South Shore is exactly where it was. Most New Yorkers are dramatically safer than they were in 1990, and nearly all New Yorkers are at least a little safer.

Block by block

Aggregated tables tell us the scale of the story, but actual people live on blocks. The NYPD's public complaint data carries a location for every complaint from 2006 on, so that is the earliest we can start telling the story at a truly local level. A complaint, in NYPD's vocabulary, is a crime reported to or recorded by the police, with one incident per record. Dozens of communities have been transformed in the past twenty years.

And precincts do not tell anywhere near the full story. Take mine, the 84th. It covers quite a tapestry of northwestern Brooklyn: the tony streets of Brooklyn Heights, the selfie sticks of DUMBO, sleepy Vinegar Hill, the office towers of MetroTech, the brownstones and bars of Boerum Hill, all the way east to Flatbush Avenue.

CellViolent complaints 2024 to 2025Rank
W 42nd St & W 43rd St6071
Schermerhorn St & Livingston St4382
E 146th St & E 147th St4153
E Fordham Rd & Marion Ave3904
Courtlandt Ave & E 153rd St3535
Food Center Dr & Halleck St3186
E 176th St & Topping Ave3187
Roosevelt Ave & 79th St3178
E Fordham Rd & E 188th St3179
Park Ave & E 117th St30510

Every 0.33-mile cell in the city, shaded by the violent complaints recorded inside it in 2024 and 2025. Murder, robbery and felony assault. The darkest of the three shades covers roughly the busiest tenth of the cells.

Violence is heavily concentrated in a small number of areas. About 2.5 percent of New York's land, just 72 of the city's 2,854 cells, holds 20 percent of its violent complaints. About 10 percent of the land, 273 cells, holds half. Those 273 cells are what is left on the map.

Since 2006, when the block-level data begins, some corners of the city have been transformed. DeKalb Ave & Clinton Ave in Fort Greene went from 43 violent complaints in 2006 to 5 in 2025, Braddock Ave & 222nd St in Queens Village from 50 to 6, and 127th Ave & Bedell St in South Jamaica from 86 to 14. Citywide over the same span, robbery fell 34 percent, felony assault rose 44 percent, and the total barely moved.

Here is the 84th measured the same way. Violent crime in the precinct fell 72 percent from 1990 to 2025, but it is up 55 percent from 2006 to 2025. The city overall has barely moved since 2006. Within the precinct, 7 cells rose and 5 fell. One cell did most of the work: Downtown Brooklyn, from 71 violent complaints in 2006 to 231 in 2025.

The Downtown Brooklyn cell ranks #2 of 2,854 citywide for 2024 and 2025, with 438 violent complaints in two years, behind only Times Square at 607. Inside it: Fulton Mall, the Hoyt-Schermerhorn station and the courthouse on Schermerhorn Street.

Interactive map in the browser: every 0.33-mile cell in New York City, violent complaints 2024 to 2025. Half of the city's violent complaints sit in 273 of its 2854 cells. Downtown Brooklyn's cell ranks #2 by count, #23 per resident, #864 per job, #822 per resident plus job.

Who lives and works here

About 8,239 people live in this cell, but 59,290 work here, and during the weekday the population booms at MetroTech, the courts and the stores. Per resident, the cell ranks #23 of 2,126 in the city, about 27 violent complaints a year for every 1,000 people who live there.

Many of those residents live in some of the most expensive new apartments in Brooklyn, a ten-minute walk from the quiet blocks of Brooklyn Heights. In the past year I have spoken with three couples with young children who moved out of this square, each naming crime and disorder as part of the reason. Counted by violent complaints per resident, the cell they left ranks #23 of 2,126 in the city.

I focus on count rather than rate because I am as interested in perceptions of safety as I am in precise likelihoods of victimization. Rates are useful for comparing across cities, but a crowd does not shield you from your own feelings of discomfort on your own street. If violent disorder on a streetscape is palpable, it is no comfort that the people around you might be the victim instead.

Hover a cell for its count and rank, click to pin it, and zoom in until the complaints appear as dots sized by how many landed at each spot.

Interactive map in the browser: pan and zoom the 2,854 map cells; hover for a cell's name, count and rank.

A month on Fulton Street

Photograph: arrive-fulton-east.

We can walk through a typical month. This is all real data from October 2025, as recorded by the NYPD. You can see, by time and by place, where crime piles up, and how that drives your perception of safety in the immediate surroundings.

Grey dots are larcenies and misdemeanor assaults; colored dots are the violent complaints. Watch where the grey piles up: two store corners on Fulton Street end the month holding 98 of the 163 larcenies and misdemeanor assaults in this circle. Every so often one of those piles turns a color, a shoplifting that became a robbery. The gold pile at Schermerhorn and Smith is 120 Schermerhorn, the Criminal Court and Central Booking, assaults recorded at the building's address at hours like 6am and 11pm, most likely inside it. The residential blocks south of Schermerhorn stay almost empty, and only two violent complaints land after 9pm. By the 31st: 24 violent complaints, 117 petit larcenies, 25 grand larcenies and 21 misdemeanor assaults within 400 meters of the station.

Interactive time-lapse in the browser: every complaint within 400 m of Hoyt-Schermerhorn in 10/2025: 24 violent, 117 petit larcenies, 25 grand larcenies, 21 misdemeanor assaults.

Violent complaints here happen disproportionately on weekday afternoons, when the stores are open and the courts are in session.

HourThis blockCity
03%5%
13%5%
22%4%
32%4%
42%4%
52%3%
62%2%
72%2%
82%3%
93%3%
105%3%
116%3%
125%3%
136%4%
147%4%
158%5%
167%5%
176%5%
185%5%
196%5%
205%6%
214%6%
224%6%
234%6%
Share of violent complaints by hour, this block vs the city, placeholder times excluded. Night (10pm to 6am): block 22%, city 36%.

A courthouse and a mall

So why did this one cell climb while the rest of Brooklyn held steady? Most of the answer is two places a few hundred feet apart, a courthouse and a mall.

The courthouse. Brooklyn's Criminal Court and Central Booking sit at 120 Schermerhorn Street, and every arrest in the borough passes through the building. Four of every five assaults on an officer within 400 meters of the station are recorded at that address, along with a steady run of felony assaults, at hours like six in the morning and eleven at night, with no premise recorded. These almost certainly happen inside, in holding, in processing, in the hallways. They make up 31% of the count that puts the cell at #2. Set that one address aside and the cell falls to #21. It is also the one series still rising this year, with 56 complaints in the first half of 2026 against 41 and 46 in the same months of 2025 and 2024.

Citywide rank of this cell, 2024 to 2025: #2 on all violent complaints, #21 without the courthouse point at 120 Schermerhorn, of 2,854 cells.

Photograph: albee-square.

The mall. City Point opened at Albee Square in 2016. Before it opened, the NYPD logged no more than 3 petit larcenies a year at this point. In 2017, the first full year, it logged 220, and in 2024 it logged 692. A small share of those thefts turn violent. Of the 43 violent complaints recorded here in 2024 and 2025, 26 were robberies, and 92% of those began as shoplifting. The other 17 were felony assaults, 6 of them on officers. The busiest hour is 2 p.m.

near Albee Square: 43 violent complaints in 2024 to 2025, 93 since 2006.

The city's Human Resources Administration also listed an EBT card office at 227 Schermerhorn Street, steps from the station, from 2023 into 2025. Violence within 200 meters of it barely changed after it opened. Across the city, I compared the blocks around every HRA and Social Security office with similar shopping blocks and found no sign that the offices push crime onto nearby streets.

What has grown since the 2010s

With the courthouse set aside, violent complaints within 400 meters of the station run at 2.2 times their 2010s level, while Brooklyn as a whole sits at 1.0. Two kinds of crime account for the rise. Robberies in stores went from about 15 a year in the 2010s to 64 a year in 2024 and 2025, and felony assaults went from about 27 a year to 78. Street robbery, the mugging most people picture when they think about crime, ran about 37 a year in the 2010s and 36 a year in 2024 and 2025.

YearStreet robberyStore robberyFelony assaultOfficer assaultAll
200649163224121
20075993029127
200848132925115
20093215262396
20105292524110
201144162614100
201242132718100
20133114271082
201434124512103
201534154119109
20163610211279
201731184619114
201836276331157
201933193121104
202015244430115
202123515732163
202218345423129
202325447838185
2024387311054275
2025365411373276
202617275637137
Violent complaints per year within 400 m of the station. 2026 is January through June.

Photograph: close-stairs.

What could help

I suspect two things could help.

Weekday afternoons. Violent complaints here peak on weekday afternoons. Only 22 percent fall between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m., against 36 percent citywide. Police and private security on Fulton Street should be heaviest then, at the City Point plaza and the two big store corners. I don't know how the NYPD schedules officers here now.

The store doors. Most of the rise is shoplifting that turns into robbery, and fights inside stores. That calls for security at the doors of the busiest stores and closer work between the stores and the 84th Precinct. Street robbery on the surrounding blocks has not risen, so more patrols there would not reach the problem.

So that is the trouble with Hoyt-Schermerhorn. Most of it is one courthouse and one mall, a short walk from some of the most expensive new apartments in Brooklyn.

Locations are NYPD-rounded points, not addresses. 2026 covers January through June. Placeholder times are excluded from hour-of-day views.